As of 2023, the proposed AirTrain project for LaGuardia Airport has been officially canceled, following significant controversy and opposition. Initially championed by former Governor Andrew Cuomo, the project aimed to connect the airport with the Mets-Willets Point subway and Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) stations. However, it faced criticism for its indirect route, high cost, and environmental impact.
Reasons for Controversy:
- Indirect Route: The AirTrain’s proposed route required travelers to head east away from Manhattan to Willets Point before doubling back towards the airport, which many deemed inefficient.
- High Costs: The project’s cost estimates ballooned from $450 million to $2.4 billion, raising concerns about financial feasibility.
- Environmental and Community Impact: Local community groups and environmental advocates opposed the project due to its potential to take away parkland and impact local property values. Legal challenges were filed against the FAA and Port Authority, citing these concerns.
In March 2023, the Port Authority announced the cancellation of the AirTrain project. Instead, an expert panel recommended expanding bus services, including a new all-electric shuttle bus running from the Astoria-Ditmars Boulevard N/W subway station to the airport. The improvements are expected to cost about $500 million, significantly less than the AirTrain, and are projected to be implemented within the next five years.